Data maturity

A maturity model is a map, not a staircase

Building step by step is safe, but too slow when competitors leap ahead. The art is knowing where to climb and where you can jump.

Ferdi Schulte · · 3 min read

Every organisation that starts with AI faces the same dilemma. Technological change is best managed step by step: first the culture and the technical base, then the next step. At the same time, AI is so far-reaching that too much caution can leave you behind AI-first competitors.

Faisal Hoque and Paul Scade show that you don't have to choose. You can do both at once, as long as you know exactly where.

Five levels of maturity

They describe a model with five levels. It starts with isolated experiments without a strategy (initial) and moves through the first repeatable applications (developing) to an AI strategy aligned with business goals, with mature data management and risk frameworks (defined). Next come fully integrated AI with measured performance (managed) and a culture of continuous innovation with seamless human–AI collaboration (optimised).

According to the authors, research among 500 listed companies showed that matching technology projects to an organisation's maturity level is an important predictor of financial success. Running before you can walk wastes money.

Use the model as a diagnosis, not a roadmap

The key insight: you cannot leapfrog as a whole organisation, but you can in targeted places. A company with little experience in predictive analytics could, for example, deploy a generative AI knowledge tool directly in one unit. The diagnosis works backwards:

  1. Identify the AI applications that deliver the most business value.
  2. For each one, map what blocks implementation on the path from today to the target state.
  3. Decide whether those blockers can be removed quickly and affordably.

Leapfrogging works best with little legacy, a strong mandate with concentrated resources, a tightly defined scope, a team that is ready and genuine strategic urgency. It does not work with deeply entangled systems, processes where failure causes serious harm, complex regulation or an organisation that is not ready. There, patience is the fastest route.

Eight questions before you scale

The business case for AI is realised when it scales, not in the pilot. Didier Bonnet and Achim Plueckebaum offer a checklist to run through at the very start:

  • Will the scaled use case contribute significantly to strategic objectives?
  • Does it solve a repeatable problem rather than a one-off?
  • Are there resources and budget to scale?
  • Is there a scalable technical foundation with shared standards?
  • Are the data sources of sustainable quality and well governed?
  • Can we manage security, compliance and ethics at scale?
  • Do we have the skills and organisation to roll out widely?
  • Is there a business owner with budget responsibility for the result?

The bottom line

A maturity assessment is therefore not a report card but a map. It shows where you need to lay the foundation first and where you can accelerate today. Curious where your organisation stands? The data scan on this site gives a first picture in three minutes.

Sources

  1. Hoque, F. & Scade, P. (2026). Strategic leapfrogging: Moving past AI maturity models with diagnostic precision. I by IMD, 18 February 2026.
  2. Bonnet, D. & Plueckebaum, A. (2025). How to scale your AI use cases: A checklist. I by IMD, 27 November 2025.

Read next

Let's talk.

About a role, an advisory question or a workshop for your team on data, analytics, AI and FP&A.